Difference between revisions of "Category talk:Magician"
m |
|||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
| − | [[User:LXD|@LXD]]: | + | [[User:LXD|@LXD]]: That is because this category is not meant to describe a general magic user. It is specifically about the occupation stage magician or illusionist, regardless of the individual's methods. (It is a subcategory of the category ''Occupation''.)<br> |
| − | For the broader, more general, practitioners of magic you are referring to check out the categories/pages called ''Category:Magic User'' and ''Category:Mage''. | + | For the broader, more general, practitioners of magic you are referring to check out the categories/pages called ''Category:Magic User'' and ''Category:Mage''. --[[User:Feronius|Feronius]] ([[User talk:Feronius|talk]]) 23:11, 2 April 2018 (UTC) |
Well then that means that real magicians are not part of this caregory unless they are performers as well. I think stage magician should become it’s own category, and both category descriptions can include caveats for either. Part of my purpose here is to add some distiction between the terms for magic users. To me, magician and mage are not the same thing. | Well then that means that real magicians are not part of this caregory unless they are performers as well. I think stage magician should become it’s own category, and both category descriptions can include caveats for either. Part of my purpose here is to add some distiction between the terms for magic users. To me, magician and mage are not the same thing. | ||
--[[User:LXD|LXD]] ([[User talk:LXD|talk]]) 03:49, 3 April 2018 (UTC) | --[[User:LXD|LXD]] ([[User talk:LXD|talk]]) 03:49, 3 April 2018 (UTC) | ||
| + | |||
| + | |||
| + | Have you already tried searching for "Category:Magic User"? Again, the category Magician ''is'' about stage magicians. That is why they listed it under Occupation.<br> | ||
| + | Separate categories already exist that are called 'Magic User', 'Mage' and a dozen more (thirteen if you count Battlemage) subcategories. --[[User:Feronius|Feronius]] | ||
Revision as of 06:43, 3 April 2018
I’d like to change this definition to something more accurate, since it is really describing a stage magician, not neccessarily a magic user. I would make it something like this;
Possibly broadest title for a person that practices magic. Magicians are known to use any or all of the more specialized disciplines. A trait common to someone described as a magician is the ability to make things ‘appear out of thin air’. This is not limited to physical items, but may include producing seemingly impossible results in a given situation. Magicians are also know for accomplishing the opposite, making something ‘disappear into thin air’. Real magicians should not be confused with stage magicians, who are more properly considered to be illusionists. (Not intended to be a definitive description as many people use the various terms for magic-users interchangeably.)
@LXD: That is because this category is not meant to describe a general magic user. It is specifically about the occupation stage magician or illusionist, regardless of the individual's methods. (It is a subcategory of the category Occupation.)
For the broader, more general, practitioners of magic you are referring to check out the categories/pages called Category:Magic User and Category:Mage. --Feronius (talk) 23:11, 2 April 2018 (UTC)
Well then that means that real magicians are not part of this caregory unless they are performers as well. I think stage magician should become it’s own category, and both category descriptions can include caveats for either. Part of my purpose here is to add some distiction between the terms for magic users. To me, magician and mage are not the same thing.
--LXD (talk) 03:49, 3 April 2018 (UTC)
Have you already tried searching for "Category:Magic User"? Again, the category Magician is about stage magicians. That is why they listed it under Occupation.
Separate categories already exist that are called 'Magic User', 'Mage' and a dozen more (thirteen if you count Battlemage) subcategories. --Feronius
